Ever since details of Marco Polo’s adventures in Medieval China began to reach Western shores, China’s image grew in the imagination of early Europeans as a land of riches and opportunities awaiting whoever was courageous enough to make the long journey there.
Now, in the twentieth century, things are not too different. Since the communist regime in China opened the country’s borders to trade, Western companies have gone to great lengths to establish business ties there.
Results, however, have been mixed, and what was often idealised as a goldmine revealed itself to be a cultural minefield. While there are of course a number of cases where Western businesses have performed successfully in China, there are others where organisations have encountered many challenges doing business in China, ranging from logistical to linguistic or cultural.
 © istockphoto.com/Tigress
|
When China first opened its economy to international trade and business in the 1980s, much of the debate in the West centred on the most effective way of gaining a stronghold in what was a new and unknown market. The majority of international companies doing business in China opted for Joint Ventures (JVs) with Chinese counterparts which ended in mixed results.
The different experiences of Western companies doing business in China shows success and failure factors vary greatly, from purely technical reasons such as low quality and uncompetitive products, to serious cultural misunderstandings as to how to work with Chinese colleagues and potential Chinese partners.
Maytag’s case in particular is one example of Western-style management gone wrong. Once the third largest manufacturer of large home appliances in the US and a company that prided itself on the use of modern management methods, Maytag entered the Chinese market through a JV with the Rongshida Group.
This had developed from a small, collectively owned enterprise and had a corporate ethic of ‘harmonious business’, so when Maytag decided to launch a restructuring programme in the face of increasing competition by other Western companies, the relationship between the JV partners eventually collapsed leading Maytag to eventually withdraw from China.
However dynamic and increasingly modern, China remains a heavily traditional society where relations – whether in business or in everyday life – are heavily dependant on a system of ‘face’ and ‘guanxi’, a term which can be translated as “relationships” or “connection”. A principle that binds friends and associates in relationships promoting trust and cooperation, ‘guanxi’ commits a friend to do what he can for another friend when called upon and violating this implies a loss of face and reputation.
Despite the many challenges of doing business in China, many companies have discovered ways of not only dealing with Chinese cultural differences but harnessing them to create very successful business ventures and opportunities in China. One of the most effective is to pre-empt any issues related to business practices and customs by providing international staff and management with cross cultural training programmes such as Communicaid’s Doing Business in China.
Maytag Case Study Source: China & World Economy (67-79, Vol. 12, No. 5, 2004)
© Communicaid Group Ltd. 2010
